transcience/docs/DECISIONS.md

# Settled decisions

Design choices the user has already made, with the reasoning. **Check here
before asking** — re-litigating a settled decision wastes a round trip, and
several of these look like defaults you would otherwise pick differently.

Ordered newest last.

---

## Simulation shape

**Game logic lives in plain `RefCounted` objects, not nodes.** No
`CharacterBody2D`, no `Area2D`, no physics server. Bullet counts make per-bullet
nodes unaffordable, the dedicated server allocates nothing, and the whole suite
runs with no `SceneTree`. Full reasoning in [ARCHITECTURE.md](ARCHITECTURE.md).

**Content is GDScript, not `.tres`.** A boss is a readable diff, there are no
resource UIDs churning in version control, and a test can build content inline.
`tools/export_content.gd` writes `.tres` copies for inspector tuning, but code
is the source of truth — port inspector edits back.

---

## Netcode

**The client sends input and nothing else.** No message exists for position,
hits, damage, or a finished escape. Having no code path is strictly stronger
than validating one.

**Bullets replicate as spawn events, not state.** ~36 bytes once per bullet;
both sides run the identical integration. Only early deaths (a hit, or a wall)
need announcing. Pinned by `tests/integration/test_replica_parity.gd`.

**No lag compensation.** Rewinding the world to a shooter's view would mean a
player who dodged on their own screen still takes the hit. If it becomes a
complaint, lag-compensate *player bullets against enemies only* — never enemy
bullets against players.

**`INPUT_MAX_LEAD` must stay well above `INPUT_LEAD_MAX`.** The server's input
acceptance window has to be wider than the band in which the client re-syncs its
own numbering. When it was not, drifting clocks landed in a dead zone where the
server silently rejected every input and the client never noticed. Pinned by
`tests/unit/test_input_lead.gd`.

---

## Combat feel

**Hitbox is smaller than the sprite** (`PLAYER_RADIUS` 6 vs
`PLAYER_VISUAL_RADIUS` 13), and `PLAYER_MUZZLE_OFFSET` derives from the visual
radius. A visible near-miss reads as fair; an invisible hit does not.

**No invulnerability frames.** Every bullet that touches you lands. I-frames
make dense patterns *safer* than sparse ones, which inverts the genre. Measured
cost: ~13.6s stationary in the Warden's opening phase. `spawn_grace` on entering
a dungeon is the sole exception, and it is a transition, not a combat mechanic.

**No contact damage.** Every threat is a bullet you can see and dodge. The
Stalker carries a point-blank shotgun rather than damaging you by touch.
`tests/unit/test_content.gd` asserts every hostile enemy has an emitter.

---

## Leaving a run

**Escape is a 1-second channel that damage does not interrupt.** An
interruptible channel makes killing the process better than pressing the button.

**A disconnect runs the same channel.** The player stays in the world as
`linkdead`, still killable. All four exits (key, menu button, clean disconnect,
SIGKILL) converge on one server-side path keyed on the socket closing — there is
deliberately no "clean leave" message. `tools/smoke.sh` asserts both the hard
kill and the polite disconnect.

**Boss rooms do not lock.** *(User, this session.)* You can always walk out of a
boss fight, and the boss cannot follow. The consequence: fights cannot rely on
trapping the player, and disengaging is always available.

---

## World

**Tile grid, generated layout, hand-authored boss arenas.** *(User, this
session.)* A grid because collision, line of sight and interest management all
become array lookups; authored arenas because a generated boss room is a bad one
about as often as a good one.

**Hard fog.** *(User, this session.)* No remembered terrain — anything outside
current line of sight is not drawn, including ground already walked over.

**Dungeon size scales with depth.** *(User, this session.)* `--depth N` is a dev
flag; what raises depth in actual play is still open.

**Never send the map, or its seed.** *(User, this session — corrected an earlier
choice of mine.)* Sending `(seed, depth)` and regenerating client-side is far
cheaper on the wire and hands any modified client the entire floor plan. Tiles
stream per peer instead. The accepted trade, in the user's words: a cheater
seeing further than they should is tolerable; seeing the whole map is not.

Consequence to preserve: the client holds *real* geometry it cannot see, because
it predicts movement against walls and simulates bullets that die on them. So
hard fog is a rendering rule, not secrecy. The secrecy is in what the server
declines to send.

---

## Identity and persistence

**Steam-shaped auth abstraction.** *(User, this session.)* The goal is
eventually Steam, so build the shape Steamworks uses and keep it swappable:
client presents an opaque ticket, server validates it and gets a stable 64-bit
account id (SteamID64's stand-in). A local dev provider persists a generated id
in `user://`, so **no Steam account is needed now**.

Not integrating GodotSteam yet: it needs a running Steam client and an app ID,
which would break the "no Steam account" requirement. Swapping it in later
should be one provider class and no schema change.

---

## Progression

**XP from kills, bosses worth far more.** *(User, this session.)* A first full
dungeon should give a bit more than is needed for the first level-up.

**Permadeath.** Death marks a character inactive — never deleted, for archival
and troubleshooting — and the player picks another character or creates one.

---

## Characters and progression

**Level 1 is base health; each level adds 10.** So level 15 is
`PLAYER_MAX_HP + 14 * 10` = 240. Level is *derived* from lifetime experience
rather than stored alongside it, so the two can never disagree — a hand-edited
save cannot produce a level 12 character with a level 3's experience.

**The five-character cap counts LIVING characters only.** Retired ones stay in
the store forever but free their slot. Counting the dead would lock a player out
of their own account permanently after five deaths, which is not a punishment
anyone signed up for.

**Death unbinds the character entirely.** There is deliberately no "return to
the hub as the character who just died" — the run is over, so the peer is
removed from the instance and left at the roster screen. The one exception is a
linkdead player, which has nobody to show a roster to, so its body is left for
the escape channel to resolve as before.

**Experience is shared across the party, undivided.** Everyone alive in the
instance receives the full amount for a kill. Splitting it would make bringing a
friend cost you progress, which is the opposite of what the hub roster exists to
encourage.

**A level-up heals by the amount it added.** Gaining a level mid-fight should
feel like relief, not like the bar you were watching got further from full.

**The character store refuses to start rather than starting empty.** A corrupt
or unreadable save aborts the server. Loading empty would look like it worked
and then overwrite every character on the first level-up.

**Account ids are written as decimal strings in JSON.** They are 64-bit and JSON
numbers are doubles, which would silently round them.

**Character swapping is hub-only, enforced on the server.** Swapping inside a
dungeon would be an instant, uninterruptible exit from danger — strictly better
than the one-second escape channel, and it would make that channel pointless.
The menu greys the button out so the rule is visible, but the server refuses
regardless of what any client's UI allows.

**Health regenerates at 0.5% of MAXIMUM per second, with no out-of-combat
gate.** A percentage rather than a flat rate, so it does not become irrelevant
at level 15 — a capped character regains 1.2 hp/s against a level 1's 0.5, and
both take about 200 seconds to heal from nothing. No combat gate because at this
rate it cannot out-heal anything actually shooting at you, and a trickle that
never stops is easier to reason about than a timer players have to learn.

**A dead character is gone, as far as the player is concerned.** Retirement is
the server's own bookkeeping for archival and troubleshooting; the roster the
client receives contains living characters only. Listing the dead would offer a
choice that cannot be taken.

**Experience rides the snapshot, not the character roster.** The roster is only
re-sent when the *set* of characters changes, so a bar fed from it moved only on
level-up or a swap. The live total is four bytes on a message that already goes
out at 20 Hz.

---

## Inventory and loot

**Four slots, permanently on screen.** An inventory you have to open is a menu,
and a menu is a death in a game where the floor is bullets. `INVENTORY_SLOTS` is
one constant that the wire format, the save record and the HUD all read, so
growing it is a one-line change — but not into a paged or scrolling UI.

**Item actions ride the input frame rather than becoming new messages.**
`InputFrame` gained `BTN_USE`, `BTN_DROP` and a slot byte. Using an item happens
*during* a fight, so it has to be ordered against movement on the same tick and
be as cheap to reject as a movement vector. Riding the existing stream gets the
redundancy that covers a dropped packet, the replay guard on `last_input_tick`,
and a rate limit of one action per tick for free. A separate reliable RPC would
have needed every one of those bolted back on.

**Item actions are edge-triggered; movement and fire are not.** The client
resends its last few frames every tick and a starved server coasts on the last
one it holds, so a level-triggered read would empty the whole inventory in four
ticks. The *slot* is part of the edge as well — tapping 2 while 1 is still held
is a second, distinct action rather than a swallowed one.

**Loot has two visibilities, and the instanced one is enforced on the wire.**
World-shared loot is one entity the first player to reach it takes.
Player-instanced loot is one entity per eligible player, and a peer is never
told the other copies exist — the filter lives in `NetCodec.encode_snapshot`
beside the actor interest radius, not in the client. It is an
interest-management rule, not a UI convention.

**The Warden's Ration is useless on purpose.** It is dropped by every boss, one
per player who was alive for the kill, and does nothing when used. Its job is to
make sure the player-instanced path runs on every single boss kill instead of
being a code path nothing exercises. If it ever gains an effect, that job needs
a new holder.

**Anything dropped becomes world-shared, whatever it was before.** An instanced
trophy you do not want should be able to reach someone who does — otherwise
"droppable" means nothing for half the items in the game.

**A potion used at full health is refused, not spent.** Nobody drinks one on
purpose at full health, so a mistimed keypress must not do it for them. The
useless ration, by contrast, *is* consumed: "does nothing" has to mean a
completed transaction or it proves nothing about the path it exists to test.

**A full bag leaves the item on the floor.** Nothing is destroyed by a failed
pickup, and the failure does not block the portal, which shares the interact
key.

**Inventories live on the character and are written on every transaction.**
Not on a timer: a crash between "picked it up" and "wrote it down" must not be a
way to lose an item, or — far worse — to duplicate one. They are stored as item
*ids* rather than wire indices, so a save survives `Items.ORDER` being appended
to, and an id this build does not know decays to an empty slot rather than to
the wrong item.

**Items do not stack.** One id per slot, no count, no charges. Everything the
game currently needs fits that, and the wire format, the save record and the UI
are all simpler for it. Add a count when something actually needs one.

**Ground loot never expires; each world caps at `MAX_LOOT_PER_INSTANCE`,
oldest evicted.** Dungeons close and take their litter with them, so only the
hub — which never closes and where players can drop things — can realistically
reach the cap.

---

## More than one dungeon

**A second dungeon is a set of multipliers over the shared content, not a
parallel copy of it.** `DungeonDef` scales enemy health, boss health and loot
chance; the generator, the rooms, the enemy mix and the boss are the same
objects the real run uses. A duplicated `Content` would drift from the original
the first time anything was tuned, and the whole value of the Proving Grounds is
that it is *identical apart from the numbers*.

**It is reachable from the hub rather than hidden behind a launch flag.** A flag
would need a server restart to switch, which makes comparing the two a chore
and makes "does this behave the same in the real run?" a question nobody
bothers to ask. Two portals a few metres apart makes it a five-second check.

**Which dungeon you enter is decided by where you are standing.** The portal is
resolved server-side from the player's own position, and the `PORTAL_USED` event
carries the answer. There is deliberately no client message that names a
dungeon: one would let any client ask for the Proving Grounds' loot rate and
walk out with it.

**The instance matcher compares dungeon ids.** A forming run only accepts party
members who asked for that kind. Without it, walking into one entrance could
drop you into the other's run purely on timing.

**Scaling clamps at both ends.** Health never scales below 1 — a creature with
zero health is a crash waiting for a divide — and a boosted drop chance never
exceeds certain, or the roll becomes dead code and "chance" stops meaning
anything.

---

## Upgrades

**Damage is `base × (1 + Σ additive) × Π multiplicative`.** The flat +5% every
upgrade carries, Spread's −10%, Doubleshot's −50% and Glass Cannon's +100% pool
into the additive term; Sniper's ×2 multiplies the result. The brief called
Sniper out as multiplicative specifically, and this is what that buys: it stays
worth taking however many percentages have already piled up, and two Snipers is
4× rather than +200%.

**The +5% belongs to *taking an upgrade*, not to any particular upgrade.** It
lives in `SimConfig.UPGRADE_DAMAGE_BONUS` and is applied once per upgrade held,
rather than being baked into seven definitions where it would be seven places
to get wrong.

**Stats are derived from the upgrade list, never stored.** `PlayerStats.build()`
recomputes them from the ids the character holds, the same way `Progression`
derives level from experience. One source of truth means a saved stat can never
disagree with the upgrades that produced it.

**Glass Cannon halves the LEVELLED maximum health, and multiplies if taken
twice.** Half of base HP would be a flat −50 that fades from brutal at level 1
to nearly free at level 15, which is the wrong direction for a drawback.

**Poison doses stack independently rather than refreshing.** Chosen over the
alternatives knowing it is by far the strongest reading: at ~4.3 shots/sec that
is dozens of concurrent doses. It costs nothing to run because every dose lasts
the same number of ticks — so they expire in the order they were added, the
pending expiries are a plain FIFO, and only its front is ever examined.

**Split Shot's children leave at ±45° from the original heading**, 90° apart,
and are born just past the target rather than on it. A child spawned inside
what was just hit would be resolved against it again on the same tick — a free
second hit, and with several charges a free chain of them.

**Level-ups queue.** Reaching two levels in one run owes two choices. Losing one
for doing well is a punishment nobody would guess at.

**The offer is rolled once and held on the character.** If it regenerated when
the screen opened, closing and reopening would be a free reroll and everyone
would press it until a legendary turned up. It is written to disk with
everything else, so a crash is not a reroll either.

**Upgrades are spent standing at the hub NPC, enforced on the server.** Same
rule as the dungeon portal: where a player is standing is the one thing a
modified client cannot fake. The screen closes when you walk away so it never
offers a button that would be refused.

**Bullet speed has a hard ceiling.** Wall collision samples a position once per
tick, so anything faster than one tile per tick tunnels through geometry. Two
Snipers would ask for 2480 u/s against a 1920 threshold, and a tunnelling
bullet looks exactly like a bullet — so `MAX_BULLET_SPEED` clamps it and a test
pins the clamp.

**Poison ticks are not announced as hits.** They land many times a second on a
reliable channel, and the client learns enemy health from the snapshot anyway.
Death is still announced, because the experience award is keyed on that event
and a kill by poison has to score.

---

## The scale of the numbers

**Health and damage are ten times what they started as, and every ratio is
unchanged.** A shot is 60, a fresh character has 1000, the Warden has 36000,
and enemy health and emitter damage were scaled with them — time to kill is
exactly what it was.

The reason is rounding, not balance. Damage is an integer, and at a base of 6
the +5% that every upgrade carries computed to 6.3 and rounded back to 6: a
player took their first upgrade, was told it made them stronger, and it did
nothing. Ten times the base means every 5% step is worth 3 damage. The same
applies to the boss's per-phase armour multiplier, which at 6 damage rounded
1.15 into 1.17.

**The practice dummy is indestructible by flag, not by a large number.** The
old 100000 health was already past the u16 the snapshot sends enemy health in,
and once a shot did 60 a patient player could have worn it down and left the
hub without a practice target until the next restart. A flag says what was
actually meant.

---

## Bosses that move, and attacks that warn

**Movement belongs to the phase, not to the boss.** A fight that stands still
and then starts hunting you is one boss with two phases. `BossDef.stationary`
was removed rather than kept alongside the phases: a flag claiming the boss
stood still while one of its phases walked around would be a second source of
truth, and the wrong one. `BossDef.moves()` is derived.

**CHASE holds a distance instead of closing.** A boss standing on top of a
player is a boss whose bullets cannot be read, and this genre cannot afford
that. It backs off when you come inside its preferred range.

**Waypoints are fractions of the arena.** The Warden's hall and the Choir Vault
are different sizes, and a phase written against absolute coordinates would only
work in one of them.

**The boss room clamp moved after movement.** It was a no-op while every boss
was stationary. Boss rooms deliberately do not lock, so walking out is always an
escape — which is only true if the boss cannot follow.

**Telegraphed strikes are announced by a stateless emitter.** Emitters are
shared resources, so nothing may be remembered between the warning and the
strike; the positions are derived from the volley number instead, and a test
asserts the burst lands where the marker promised.

**Telegraph markers are drawn through fog and through walls**, unlike every
other thing in the view. A warning you cannot see is an unavoidable hit with
extra steps, which is the opposite of what a telegraph is for.

**Which boss a run has comes from its seed, not its depth.** Depth is a dev flag
that nothing in play raises, so keying the arena to it meant the second boss
existed and no player could ever reach it.